Log in
New!
Back to the Growing Debate on China vs. Japan
China now looks more and more like Japan in the 1990s and 2000s. Private demand has tanked, interest rates are falling through the floor and the government is forced to run large, endless deficits to offset the malaise. On this headline basis there are very strong parallels with "Japanization".
On the one hand, the good news is that China doesn't have the private balance sheet overhang that Japan did. Households may not be spending today but they don't have any underlying need to build down leverage. Nor do most corporates. I.e., in theory at least, there's no reason domestic demand couldn't resurge tomorrow.
The bad news, though, is that things are nonetheless getting worse rather than better. In practice private demand and sentiment continue to weaken - and the malaise is now at risk of being "institutionalized" by the ongoing collapse of marriage and birth rates in the country. So even without the same private balance sheet overhang, the mainland could still easily wind up in the same place.
There's also the unfortunate and unusual fact that China is busy locking the economy up behind walls in a way that Japan never did, with very little hope of reopening. In this sense, it's not just "Japanization" we worry about ... it's "North Korea-ization".
Back to the Growing Debate on China vs. Japan (PDF)
How To Think About Emerging Markets (2026 Edition)
An opinionated guide to emerging markets
What is an Emerging Market? (How to Think About Emerging Markets, 2026 Edition, Part 1)What's Wrong With EM? (How to Think About Emerging Markets, 2026 Edition, Part 2)
Who Makes It, Who Doesn't (How to Think About Emerging Markets, 2026 Edition, Part 3)
Is Globalization Over? (How to Think About Emerging Markets, 2026 Edition, Part 4)
Four EM Growth Fallacies (How to Think About Emerging Markets, 2026 Edition, Part 5)
An Austrian Primer: Savings, Debt and Default (How to Think About Emerging Markets, 2026 Edition, Part 6)
Life After China (How to Think About Emerging Markets, 2026 Edition, Part 7)
Macro and EM Equities (How to Think About Emerging Markets, 2026 Edition, Part 8)
Macro and EM Debt (How to Think About Emerging Markets, 2026 Edition, Part 9)
Macro and EM Currencies (How to Think About Emerging Markets, 2026 Edition, Part 10)
How To Think About China (2025 Edition)
... and an opinionated guide to China
Lies, Damn Lies and Statistics (How to Think About China 2025 Edition, Part 1)A State Economy or a Market Economy? (How to Think About China 2025 Edition, Part 2)
The End of the Miracle (How to Think About China 2025 Edition, Part 3)
Property Boom and Property Bust (How to Think About China 2025 Edition, Part 4)
Debt, Banks and the Budget (How to Think About China 2025 Edition, Part 5)
The Future of the Renminbi and the Closing of China (How to Think About China 2025 Edition, Part 6)
The Aging Crisis (How to Think About China 2025 Edition, Part 7)
How to Follow Macro Policy (How to Think About China 2025 Edition, Part 8)
Why Haven't I Made Money? (How to Think About China 2025 Edition, Part 9)
